Songfacts Says On December 18 2010 It Was Announced That Josh And Zac Farro Were Leaving Paramore. The Departure Was Bitter With Josh Whom Hayley Dated For A Time Claiming There Was A Lot More Going On Behind The Scenes Than Most Fans Were Aware Of. Hayley Responded To MTV With The Revelation That The Majority Of The Songs On Brand New Eyes Were About Him. This Presented A New Light On Such Lyrics As This Song's "It Has To Be So Lonely/ To Be The Only One Who's Holy."